Introduction:
Evans Above is the first novel in Rhys Bowen’s Constable Evans mystery series, which introduces readers to a quaint, sleepy village in Wales named Llanfair. This cozy mystery, originally published in 1997,

marks the debut of Constable Evan Evans, a charming and mild-mannered police officer whose quiet demeanor belies his sharp mind and dedication to solving crime. The novel is an exemplary introduction to Bowen’s style, known for her light-hearted approach, vivid character portrayals, and a setting that is as much a character as the people who inhabit it.

Plot Overview:
The story begins with Constable Evan Evans, affectionately called “Evans the Law” by the village inhabitants, moving to Llanfair after a stint in the more bustling town of Swansea. Llanfair seems like the perfect place for a quiet life, but the illusion of tranquility is shattered when two hikers are found dead on Mount Snowdon, the highest peak in Wales. Initially thought to be accidental deaths, Evans begins to suspect foul play as he digs deeper, noticing inconsistencies that others overlook.

Simultaneously, Evans is drawn into the small-town dynamics of Llanfair, where the community is close-knit but filled with secrets and old grudges. The murder mystery unravels against this backdrop, with Evans navigating through village politics, eccentric characters, and the challenges of living in a place where everyone knows everyone else.

Character Development:
Rhys Bowen crafts a compelling protagonist in Constable Evans. He is portrayed as a man of integrity and intelligence, with a deep sense of duty to his community. While he may not be the most ambitious or aggressive detective, his methodical approach and attention to detail make him effective in uncovering the truth. His relationship with the villagers, from the flirtatious barmaid to the eccentric old-timers, adds layers to his character, highlighting his ability to balance professional obligations with personal connections.

The supporting cast is equally vivid. Each character in Llanfair is distinct, with their own quirks and backstories that add richness to the narrative. Bowen has a talent for infusing even minor characters with life, making them memorable despite limited page time. The interactions among the villagers, filled with humor and warmth, are a key part of the novel’s charm.

Setting and Atmosphere:
The setting of Llanfair, nestled in the Welsh countryside, is one of the most appealing aspects of Evans Above. Bowen captures the beauty and isolation of the region, from the rugged landscapes of Mount Snowdon to the cozy interiors of the village pub. The atmosphere is quintessentially cozy, with the village itself almost acting as a character within the story. The tight-knit community, the slow pace of life, and the constant hum of gossip create an environment that is both charming and stifling, reflecting the dual nature of life in such a small place.

Themes:
Several themes run through Evans Above, the most prominent being the contrast between appearance and reality. The idyllic village setting is initially presented as a peaceful haven, but as Evans digs deeper, the darker undercurrents of human nature come to the fore. Bowen explores how secrets can fester in small communities, and how the veneer of respectability can hide a multitude of sins.

Another theme is the clash between modernity and tradition. Llanfair, with its deep-rooted traditions and resistance to change, is juxtaposed against the broader world that Constable Evans has experienced outside the village. This tension is evident in the way the villagers react to the investigation and how they perceive outsiders.

Writing Style:
Rhys Bowen’s writing is accessible and engaging, with a light touch that makes Evans Above an easy, enjoyable read. Her descriptions are vivid without being overly detailed, allowing readers to picture the Welsh countryside and the cozy village life effortlessly. The dialogue is natural and often laced with humor, capturing the wit and warmth of the Welsh people.

Bowen’s pacing is steady, with the mystery unfolding at a measured pace. She balances the development of the plot with the exploration of characters and setting, ensuring that neither aspect overshadows the other. While the mystery itself is not overly complex, it is well-crafted, with enough twists to keep readers guessing until the end.

Critique:
While Evans Above is a delightful read, it may not appeal to readers looking for a fast-paced, high-stakes thriller. The book’s charm lies in its subtlety and the gradual unfolding of the mystery, which might feel too slow for some. Additionally, the novel adheres closely to the conventions of the cozy mystery genre, which means it avoids graphic violence and dark themes. This might be a limitation for those who prefer their mysteries with a bit more grit.

Another potential critique is that while the characters are well-drawn, they can sometimes verge on being caricatures. The eccentricities of the villagers, while amusing, can occasionally feel exaggerated, which might detract from the story’s realism.

Conclusion:
Evans Above is a charming and well-crafted introduction to the world of Constable Evans and the village of Llanfair. Rhys Bowen succeeds in creating a cozy mystery that is both engaging and comforting, with a protagonist who is easy to root for and a setting that feels like home. The novel is perfect for fans of the cozy mystery genre, offering a gentle but intriguing puzzle set against the backdrop of a picturesque Welsh village. While it may not be the most groundbreaking or intense mystery, it is a thoroughly enjoyable read that sets the stage for a promising series.